CART MENU Open menu The Mackinac Fudge Shop Toggle search bar What can we help you find? Submit search CART Gourmet Fudge Candies Hand Dipped Chocolates Old Fashioned Candies Bark Popcorn Gift Boxes Fudge of the Month Club Favors Occasions Birthday & Anniversary Business Gifts Holiday Gifts Wedding Favors Categories Best Sellers Custom Mix Top Rated What's New Nav Menu 4 Nav Menu 5 Nav Menu 6 Nav Menu 7 Nav Menu 8 Home > Best Sellers Sort By: Price: Low to High Price: High to Low Most Popular Title Manufacturer Newest Oldest Availability 9 per page 18 per page 36 per page 54 per page 90 per page Page of 2 Mackinac Fudge - 3 Slice Box Our Price: $22.95 Mackinac Fudge - 6 Slice Box Our Price: $39.95 Chocolate Dipped Butter Toffee with Pecans Our Price: $13.95 Mix and match any three of our Gourmet Mackinac Island Fudge Flavors in this three slice gift box. Each slice is approx. 1/2 lb. Mix and match any six of our Gourmet Mackinac Island Fudge Flavors in this three slice gift box. Each slice is approx. 1/2 lb. Homemade chocolate dipped butter toffee rolled in pecans. Turtles Our Price: $13.95 Fudge of the Month Club - 3 Month Subscription Our Price: $79.95 Custom Gift Box #1 Our Price: $47.95 Our decadent homemade turtles. Giant pecans covered in caramel and chocolate. 3 month subscription to the Fudge of the Month Club. Custom Gift Box #2 Our Price: $69.95 Custom Chocolates Gift Sampler Our Price: $36.95 Custom Chocolates Gift Tower Our Price: $59.95 Choose any 3 of our hand dipped chocolates, old fashioned candies and chocolate barks to be sent in a beautiful gift assortment. Choose any 5 of our hand dipped chocolates, old fashioned candies and chocolate barks to be sent in a beautiful gift tower.